Japan’s Designated Secrets Law: All you ever wanted to know but should be afraid to ask. (LOL)

On December 7th, the ruling bloc of the Japanese government passed into law a Secrecy bill which many feel threatens freedom of the speech and the freedom of the press.

For those who are interested in finding more about Japan’s Designated Secrets Law, here are source materials that you may find useful.  These are material distributed to the foreign press by the Cabinet Office last week before the bill became law. The Abe cabinet promised to set up an oversight committee to oversee the use of the ability to classify information a “specially designated secret” but the law itself does not mandate such restraints. The proposed oversight agency or oversight office will have no independence from the government.

When we have a complete Japanese draft of the law, we will post it. Any comments on the materials or suggestions for other reference materials that should be posted are welcome.

2. Overview Cover

This a summary of the secrecy law. Although the categories for which secrets can be designated are limited to four areas, there is no oversight to determine whether or not the designation is properly applies. Note the + "Requires special need for secrecy" which is a clause so wide that conceivably anything could be fit into that heading.
This a summary of the secrecy law. Although the categories for which secrets can be designated are limited to four areas, there is no oversight to determine whether or not the designation is properly applies. Note the + “Requires special need for secrecy” which is a clause so wide that conceivably anything could be fit into that heading.
3. Overview Page 1
The actual text of the law defines terrorism as also “forcing one’s opinions on others.” This is the basis of Shigeru Ishiba, Secretary General of the LDP (ruling party) stating that those noisily protesting the bill were committing acts tantamount to terrorism.
6. Overview Page 4
The Lawyer’s Federation of Japan points out that if a journalist or citizen were to stubbornly ask about SDS (specially designated secrets) to a government official that this could be construed as “instigation of leakage” and result in him/her being called in for questioning, their laptops and phones seized, possible arrest and conviction. Even when acting in the public interest, and without knowing they were seeking information about a “specially designated secret” an individual would still face up a year in prison or a fine under 300,000 yen.

4. Overview Page 2 5. Overview Page 3


“May I have some more whale, sir….”

In the United States, serving whale meat can cost you decades of jail-time as one sushi chef in Los Angeles recently learned; in Japan it costs you about $10, for the whale tempura special (¥980)*. If you go to one of Tokyo’s most famous whale specialty restaurants, Ganso Kujiraya (The Original Whale Seller), on a weekday, you can sometimes have the raw whale sashimi set for the same price; it comes with fresh ginger, soy sauce, salad, a steaming bowl of rice, and soup. While you’re there, you can pick up some whale bacon too as a souvenir. On a Saturday, elderly sisters visiting Tokyo stopped the restaurant to try out the advertised specials. “We were passing by and saw the sign and got nostalgic. It’s been decades since we ate any.”  When asked how the tempura special was, the oldest sister replied in a hushed voice, “It’s a little dry and not as tasty as I remember. Try the whale bacon or the whale steak, that’s probably much better.”

The two ladies debated the intelligence of the animals briefly and then tried to explain what whale tasted like. One felt it tasted like inoshishi (wild boar). The younger sister said, “After  the 3/11 (nuclear meltdown), I’m not sure I’d eat wild boar. They apparently are full of cesium. Radioactive.” When we pointed out that whale meat was sometimes known to have high levels of mercury, the eldest sister laughed and said, “Well, I guess there’s nothing safe to eat then,” and went back to enjoying her meal.

Many younger generations in Japan have never even eaten whale meat. Many of the older Japanese who ate it remember it as something served in school lunches during Japan’s post-war recovery. Toshio Nagashima, a 54 year old truck driver in Tokyo, says, “I remember eating it years ago. I can’t say it’s something I crave now. But I might eat some it if it was fresh. I hear the good stuff tastes like basashi (raw horse meat.)” A majority of the population in Japan have never had the experience of feasting on whale.

Well, there is some good news for the new generation–if you’re a kid enrolled in the Japanese public schools, your chances of getting to eat it in 2013 are twice as good as they were last year. The demand for whale appears to be declining and that appears to be driving the Japanese government’s efforts to get today’s youngsters to develop a taste for “the other red meat.”

Whale bacon, whale sashimi (raw whale) and whale tempura at Japanese restaurant
Whale sashimi (raw whale) and whale tempura at speciality Japanese restaurant


Japan’s Fisheries Agency said that the state-funded Japan Institute of Cetacean Research (JICR) would sell whale meat acquired for its “scientific research” directly to individuals and restaurants this year. The institute also plans to double its distribution of whale meat to school-lunch programs, despite the high level of mercury contained in whale meat, by reducing prices. The Japan Institute of Cetacean Research is under the supervision of the Fisheries Agency and most of its funding comes from the Japanese government.

According to the Mainichi News, about 100 metric tons of whale meat is served in school lunches per year in Japan. The Ministry of Education says that it encourages schools to serve local specialities to their students, as long as the dishes meet the national nutritional standards set per meal for children. In Tokyo, the Higashi-machi and Shibaura elementary school in the Minato ward served whale meat this January as part of their traditional meals menu. “We do not serve whale meat just because it is cheaper than pork or beef, but to teach children about the kind of school lunches Japan had in the past,” a spokeswoman from Higashi-machi elementary school said. “Our whale meat lunch is one of our most popular menu items,” she added. The Minato-ward Board of Education insisted that schools do not serve whale meat every day to its students.

*For the rest of the story, please go here, to The Daily BeastI’ll Have The Whale, Please: Japan’s Unsustainable Whale Hunts